Thank you to all participants! 3D Technology is really excited about the solutions you created and found your feedback throughout the Challenge to be really helpful in focusing on safety and comfort. You can expect them to pick and pull the best features from all of the winners as they pursue this product. Great work GrabCADrs!
We really like this design. It not only looks good, it is well-though out and also looks strong. A body builder will take one look at this and know that it could withstand quite a bit of weight but still be comfortable enough.
Safe and durable: 1
Modern and appealing: 1
Comfort and ergonomic: 4
Cost: 2
Nice! This design makes you want to spend all your time at the gym doing Donkey Calf Raises. We like the rugged look and that comfort was a consideration.
Safe and durable: 3
Modern and appealing: 6
Comfort and ergonomic: 2
Cost: 3
We like the use of the clamp function. It's both simple and functional! The design also really caught our attention. We are concerned that while it is simple in construction, compared to the other entries, it would be more expensive to produce.
Safe and durable: 4
Modern and appealing: 4
Comfort and ergonomic: 3
Cost: 13
We like this compact, lightweight, and contoured design. It looks attractive but we are wondering about the comfort level for gym goers compared to the other solutions.
Safe and durable: 5
Modern and appealing: 2
Comfort and ergonomic: 12
Cost: 6
This well thought-out design is also refreshingly different and eye-catching! Our concern is how the device isn't contoured for comfort and attaches to the barbell. Compared to other solutions it may have trouble handling large weight loads over time.
Safe and durable: 9
Modern and appealing: 3
Comfort and ergonomic: 13
Cost: 7
The unique locking mechanism and strap are great additions. The design thinking was explained well and we appreciate the details on all the parts used. Comfort and safety are its biggest assets.
Safe and durable: 8
Modern and appealing: 10
Comfort and ergonomic: 1
Cost: 14
Simple and easy to make are the big wins with this design. Great job! We are concerned about the c-clamps as the barbell attachment. It is more likely to slip away from the bar while the user is exercising than our other options.
Safe and durable: 11
Modern and appealing: 7
Comfort and ergonomic: 10
Cost: 5
Nice work! This design looks simple, flexible and comfortable. It didn't overachieve in any category, but did a nice job of hitting all our concerns.
Safe and durable: 7
Modern and appealing: 9
Comfort and ergonomic: 7
Cost: 10
Simplicity, performance, and even sustainability were part of this design. Nicely done! It fell short in design and didn't feel modern.
Safe and durable: 6
Modern and appealing: 13
Comfort and ergonomic: 11
Cost: 4
A truly unique design. It comes across as both sporty and sturdy but the overall design isn't as simple and modern as we'd like. There are many parts which causes concerns for cost. A great idea that could be refined in the future to further optimize comfort and appeal.
Safe and durable: 13
Modern and appealing: 11
Comfort and ergonomic: 6
Cost: 12
We like the minimalistic saddle shape used in this design. Our concerns are around the attaching device and its safety.
Safe and durable: 14
Modern and appealing: 8
Comfort and ergonomic: 14
Cost: 9
We admire the rugged design and think the addition of springs is interesting, but the look isn't modern enough and we are a bit worried about safety of the attachment.
Safe and durable: 15
Modern and appealing: 12
Comfort and ergonomic: 9
Cost: 11
Talk about a different approach! We love the creativity and effort From Joe. Our biggest concern is the extra cost a stand alone option creates and we are worried about the comfort of the user.
Safe and durable: 10
Modern and appealing: 14
Comfort and ergonomic: 8
Cost: 15
This is a nice effort that should be recognized. We don't feel the attachment would be safe or comfortable compared to the others. You really don't want the device to slide during use. We are a bit worried about cost to manufacture, but it is simple.
Safe and durable: 12
Modern and appealing: 15
Comfort and ergonomic: 15
Cost: 8
If you don't receive the email within an hour (and you've checked your Spam folder), email us as confirmation@grabcad.com.