And the winners are...

Thank you to everyone who participated! With so many unique and interesting designs, picking the finalists, and ultimately the winners, for this challenge was not an easy task.

We arrived at the top 10 finalists by filtering the entries using our selection criteria. We then actually printed the top designs and tested them at our lab. We loaded the part and recorded its peak load before failure. Taking that load, we then calculated the strength-to-weight value for each part and ranked them.

The winners were the one with the best strength-to-weight ratio. All the parts can be easily manufactured via additive and are all ranked equally in that regards.

Congratulations to the winners and all of the finalists!

Wudhidham Prachumsri, Alcoa

How the finalists were chosen

To select the finalist designs, a systematic approach was taken. We began by checking for envelope fitment; any designs that did not fit the envelope requirements were disqualified. The remaining designs were then ranked by mass.

Starting from the lightest design, we performed FEA simulation on over 150 submitted designs to down-select the top designs. Although many entries had included FEA simulation, several of the boundary conditions utilized did not capture the flexibility of a bolted connection between the bearing bracket and the base plate. This interaction is influenced by the preload exerted on the joint element by the fasteners when they are installed. Since some of the submitted FEA utilized fixed constraints around the bolt holes, simulation results produced incorrect stress values.

The designs that passed our standardized FEA analysis were then evaluated based on their ease of DMLS printing and post processing cost, and were narrowed down to the finalists that are listed below.

Wudhidham Prachumsri, Alcoa

1st Place Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Winner
ALCOA BRACKET (BRCT 12a) correction by igor.nikol-1

ALCOA BRACKET (BRCT 12a) correction

Mass: 220.509 grams
Ultimate Load: 4968 lbf

Strength/Weight: 22.53 lbf/grams

Alcoa

2nd Place Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Winner
Bracket Concept A by allar.ounsaar

Bracket Concept A

Mass: 285.206 grams
Ultimate Load: 6181 lbf

Strength/Weight: 21.67 lbf/grams

Alcoa

3rd Place Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Winner
Elephant Bracket V2.1 by krisztian.haasz-1

Elephant Bracket V2.1

Mass: 254.411 grams
Ultimate Load: 4974 lbf

Strength/Weight: 19.55 lbf/grams

Alcoa

Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Finalist
Airplane Bearing Bracket by dimitar.karaveziyski-1

Airplane Bearing Bracket

Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Finalist
Bracket Mstgermain by marc.st.germain-1

Bracket Mstgermain

Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Finalist
DMLS Aircraft Bracket Challenge by j.f.gomez-1

DMLS Aircraft Bracket Challenge

Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Finalist
WJDAE - ABBC1 Strongarm by winston.jennings-1

WJDAE - ABBC1 Strongarm

Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Finalist
Optimized Alcoa Bearing Bracket V1.0-REV 1 by ardhia.pramesti-2

Optimized Alcoa Bearing Bracket V1.0-REV 1

Alcoa Bearing Bracket Challenge Finalist
AMTech Bracket by paolo.minetola-1

AMTech Bracket
We have updated our terms in order to better protect your hard work and keep our challenges running smoothly! To submit your challenge entry, please read and accept the new Challenge Terms and Conditions.

Save Cancel