Ask and answer engineering questions

Learn from millions of experts

Feed

Why is Projected Geometry locked?

By Art Andrews on 08 Feb 12:07 5 answers 555 views 2 comments

When working in an assembly, I edit a part, create new sketch and project geometry to the sketch plane. Sometimes the geometry appears with the color yellow and will move location when the original geometry is moved. Sometimes the geometry appears with the color blue and will have the Locked Constraints with it. This geometry WILL NOT move when the original geometry is moved. Can anyone tell me why?

5 answers

  • Jonathan DeRoner
    Jonathan DeRoner 8 months ago

    The reason being is because when an object (part, or assembly) isn't fully constrained within an assembly, it can be moved and dragged around. If you move them, the sketch moves with whatever you moved. If a part or assembly is fully constrained, the sketch will not move unless the surface or part that is being sketched on is moved.

    This is a standard with any design software. The best way to go about this is rather than edit a part using sketches in assembly, you edit the part individually by opening it, or right clicking the part and then click edit. Editing within an assembly file is never a good practice. The edits you make there do not directly effect the part files themselves. Only what appears in the assembly file.

  • Jonathan DeRoner
    Jonathan DeRoner 8 months ago

    I see what has happened. This is a problem that is very common. What has happened is you are referencing geometry from another part in an assembly. This is something you want to avoid at all costs and is what is creating your problem. Since the left and right side parts are practically the same, you can save a copy of the left side part, mirror it, and then save that as the right side part since they are identical on the inside face. That would solve one problem. The left side part is referencing the bottom plate part also. Changes in the bottom plate, change part other parts also. This can also cause it to be unconstrained. Whenever making parts, NEVER (if possible) reference geometry from another part in an assembly for future reference. That is what the rotation symbol in the feature tree means. I will fix this for you and post parts shortly.

  • Jonathan DeRoner
    Jonathan DeRoner 8 months ago

    Here are the revised files. RS1 is the replacement for the original RS. I'm using inventor 2017 so if your version is older. I can submit step files on here which are universal.

    Attachments

    BTM PANEL.ipt, 125 KB
    Download
    EP-LS.ipt, 128 KB
    Download
    EP-RS.ipt, 102 KB
    Download
    EP-RS1.ipt, 134 KB
    Download
    PROJECTED GEOMETRY TEST.iam, 103 KB
    Download

Add your answer to: "Why is Projected Geometry locked?"

Save Cancel