Ask and answer engineering questions

Learn from millions of experts

Feed

Sweep or extrude

By Tendai Katsuwa on 22 Sep 09:31 5 answers 299 views 3 comments

To sweep or extrude in AutoCAD, which is better?

5 answers

  • Riolito Paildelan
    Riolito Paildelan 11 months ago

    Hi Tendai Katsuwa,

    I would say both are very useful. Extrude is most used for applying volume perpendicular to a 2d plane such as a box, cylinder. While sweep is mostly for applying volume along a path. like spring, handle etc.

    Basically, importance of both will be different from case to case.

    There are also times that extrude does not work. A possible cause is an unclosed polygon that is supposed to be extruded. But at rare times from my experience it is a software bug or software is unresponsive. So what I do is I make a path to an axis that I desire and sweep the 2d plane to it so it would have a volume to make a box/cylinder. If it still won't work, I redraw.

    There are also instances that sweep can be an alternative for revolve or vise versa but for circular path only. Before, I had also experienced that the object I wanted to revolve doesn't work. A possible cause is an unclosed polygon also but there are rare times that it is also caused by a bug/ the software is unresponsive. So instead of revolving the 2d plane I make a circular path and sweep on it. And If it also still won't work, I redraw, too.

    Don't forget to "upvote" below the comment if this aided what you are aiming for and don't hesitate to ask if you have any more questions.
    If you got any other questions or anything, just submit an entry on the link below.
    link:
    https://grabcad.com/questions/new

    Thank you Tendai Katsuwa!

    regards,
    Riolito Paildelan

  • Robert H.
    Robert H. 11 months ago

    I would say neither is better than the other. They are simply different tools.

    Generally speaking, the added hassle of constructing a path for sweep features makes it less appealing to use when a simple extrude will suffice.

  • Sudhir Gill
    Sudhir Gill 11 months ago

    depends upon which AutoCAD version you are using. Also the application, and profile for extruding.

  • seumas macaskill
    seumas macaskill 7 months ago

    I would say that by becoming familiar with as many functions as possible then you can adapt all of your skills and techniques to suit the task in hand. Extrude is the most simple tool to use and understand so it's a good starting point.

Add your answer to: "Sweep or extrude"

Save Cancel