Why does my object rotate when using Copy with Mates?

I insert part into assembly drawing. I rotate it using the little box that pops up. I then mate the part hole with another part hole. I then mate again with a face to face mate (coincident). That part lines up and is in the correct position. I then go to the Copy with Mate command and select the hole I want to repeat to. Then I select the same face. It then places the part at the correct hole location but it is rotated and not straight like the first part.